How To Make Beef Stroganoff with Noodles

If the words “Beef Stroganoff” seem intimidating, you’re not the only one. It sounds fancy, like something you would find on restaurant menus or that only experienced home cooks can handle. But here’s the truth: it’s one of the easiest dishes to make. Once you try it, it will become a regular part of your weekly dinner plans.

This dish features tender strips of beef seared to a beautiful golden brown. It’s mixed with a rich, creamy sour cream sauce that is savory, slightly tangy, and full of flavor. It all sits on a bed of soft, buttery egg noodles that soak up every bit of that amazing sauce. The kind of meal that creates a hush at the dinner table.

And today, I’ll show you how to make it at home.

This recipe is made for beginner cooks. There are no complicated techniques, hard-to-find ingredients, or guesswork involved. I’ll guide you through every single step, from picking the right cut of beef to the simple trick that prevents your sauce from separating. By the time you sit down to eat, you will feel like you’ve been making this dish for years.

How To Make Beef Stroganoff with Buttered Noodles

• 2lbs/1kg thin cut sirloin or filet mignon
• 450g/1lb pasta ( any pasta of your choice )
• 450g/1lb Crimini or button mushrooms ( sliced )
• 400g or 1 2/3c beef broth (homemade or store bought)
• 3 packets of powdered gelatin (for the beef broth)
• 200g/1 med white onion, medium diced
• 175g/1 glass dry white wine
• 50g or 3Tbsp soy sauce (for marinade)
• 35g or 2Tbsp Worcestershire
• 4-5 large garlic cloves ( minced )
• oil (canola, grapeseed, or avocado )
• Salt
• 25g or 1.5Tbsp tomato paste
• 15g or 2Tbsp ap flour
• 25g 1 2/3Tbsp Dijon mustard
• 3g or 1.5tsp black pepper
• 65g/.5 stick unsalted butter, cut into chunks
• 75g or 1/3c heavy cream

1. Start by tenderizing the beef with a fork. Poke each side of the sirloin to break down the protein structure. This will make the meat more tender.

2. Place both steaks into a freezer bag. Add 50 grams of soy sauce and 15 grams of Worcestershire sauce. This simple marinade will help further break down the proteins in the meat, making it even more tender. Leave it in the fridge for about 15 to 20 minutes.

3. Take your onion and dice it into medium-sized pieces. Don’t cut them too small, as they will shrink further while cooking.

4. Next, slice the mushrooms into medium slices. Avoid cutting them too thick.

5. Mince or press your garlic cloves.

6. Fill a medium-large pot with water and place it on the stove to bring it to a boil. Set a heavy-bottomed pot on the other side over high heat.

7. Remove the marinated, tenderized beef from the fridge. Lay the steaks out on double-lined paper towels and dab them until dry.

8. Add some oil to the pan and gently place the steaks in one at a time. We want the steak to brown well, so press them down for better contact with the hot pot.

9. After 2 to 3 minutes, the steaks should be well browned. Flip them to brown the other side as well.

10. After another 2 to 3 minutes, the other side should be nicely done.

11. Remove the steaks from the pot and let them rest on a plate.

12. In the same pot used for the steaks, make the mushroom sauce. Add some oil, then add all the mushrooms and a pinch of salt. Stir to combine. As the mushrooms cook, they will release water, which will help deglaze the fond (the caramelized brown bits) stuck to the bottom.

13. After about two minutes, use a wooden spoon to scrape up the seared beef bits from the pot’s bottom.

14. Continue to sauté the mushrooms for another two to three minutes. When they start to feel dry, add the chopped white onion along with another strong pinch of salt to draw out more water from the onions.

15. Sauté the onions and mushrooms together over high heat for three to four minutes, stirring every minute. They should become nicely caramelized.

16. Add the garlic and continue to sauté for about 10 to 15 seconds.

17. Next, pour in a glass of white wine. Use the wooden spoon to scrape the pot’s bottom and let it simmer for about 1 to 2 minutes.

18. Then add 25 grams of tomato paste and 15 grams of all-purpose flour.

19. Once the mixture looks nicely glazed, it’s time to add the broth to help deglaze.

20. For this recipe, use gelatin-infused beef broth to mimic the effect of a full-bodied broth that’s simmered for hours. To do this, add three packets of powdered gelatin to beef broth and stir to combine. Now you have a stock that improves the overall texture of the sauce.

21. After adding the beef broth, stir well to get the pot’s bottom clean. Bring the gelatin stock to a simmer to ensure the powder gets fully incorporated before adding anything else.

22. Next, add 25 grams of Dijon mustard, 20 grams of Worcestershire sauce, and 3 grams of freshly ground black pepper. Stir to combine, then reduce the heat to low. Let it simmer for about 10 minutes with a lid on.

23. While the mushroom sauce simmers, it’s time to cook the noodles. When the water is boiling, add a good pinch of salt and then the pasta. Stir quickly to avoid sticking together and cook according to package instructions, which should be about eight to nine minutes.

24. After eight minutes of boiling, the pasta should be cooked perfectly; not crunchy, with a little chew, and definitely not overcooked.

25. Drain the pasta in the sink but don’t fully drain it; leave about a quarter cup of pasta water. This will help the butter stick when added. Once drained, add just over half a stick (about 65 grams) of butter to the pot. Stir to emulsify as it melts. The butter and pasta water will mix to create a silky sauce that coats each noodle. Set your pasta aside.

26. Slice the sirloin that you set aside earlier. Cut it against the grain into thin slices for maximum tenderness. Once sliced, cut them again into perfect bite-sized pieces.

27. The sauce should be thickened now, with everything tender and flavorful. To finish the sauce, add 75 grams of heavy cream and stir to combine. The cream will help balance the acidity from the white wine and round off the flavors perfectly.

28. Finally, add in all of the sliced beef. Stir to combine, cover with a lid, and simmer over low heat for just another minute or two to incorporate the steak into the mushroom sauce.

29. After 2 minutes of low simmering, the beef is cooked, and the sauce should be glossy and ready. Turn off the heat and taste for seasoning, adjusting it as needed.

30. To serve, plate some of the velvety buttered noodles and top with a little of the stroganoff sauce.

31. Finish with fresh parsley and dill.

What to serve with Beef Stroganoff

Classic option of course is beef  stroganoff over buttered egg noodles. Finish with parsley and a lot of black pepper.

Cozy swaps: Mashed potatoes, amazing with the sauce Rice or buttered spaetzle Roasted baby potatoes

Lighter bases: Cauliflower mash Zucchini noodles Roasted broccoli as a bowl base

Side dishes to balance the richness Choose one crisp or green side. Green beans, roasted or sautéed Roasted broccoli or asparagus Simple salad with a tangy vinaigrette Cucumber salad for crunch.

Tips to make the very best beef stroganoff

• Slice beef thin and against the grain. This is the trick for extra tender sirloin.
• Always sear in batches. crowding the pot makes the beef steam instead of brown.
• Brown the mushrooms until the pan looks dry. That’s when the flavor shows up.
• Thicken the sauce before adding sour cream. The sauce should be thick enough to coat a spoon first.
• Keep the heat low after adding sour cream. Never ever not let a sauce that contains heavy cream boil.
• Always taste at the end and adjust the seasoning accordingly. Salt, pepper, Dijon, and Worcestershire can quickly fix a dish that feels “flat”.

Check Out More Dinner Recipe Ideas!

Creamy Marry Me Chicken

How to Make Stuffed Bell Peppers

Old Fashioned Crockpot Beef Stew

Easy Homemade Chicken Pot Pie

Easy Mississippi Pot Roast